|
Young
People
War Prayers
Dim Mak Records
Guest review by Matt
Whipkey
L.A.'s
The Young People are undoubtedly a critics' favorite. Writers and
reviewers alike praise the band for nearly single handedly developing
a new genre of music: avant-Americana. On War Prayers, The
Young People definitely deliver the avant-goods. Unfortunately,
it comes at the expense of melody and cohesive song structures.
It's apparent that this
band is out to experiment with the modern-day concept of song, twisting
and turning their compositions every which way. Needless to say
this makes for an extremely uneasy listen. Some may call them a
challenging band; a terribly mediocre and tuneless group is more
appropriate.
Salvation comes in the
form of Katie Eastburn's vocals. It is her calming lyrical delivery
that saves the album from being a complete throwaway. After several
listens, Eastburn's vocals take on a near mythic form, conjuring
up ghosts of America's musical past. It is a shame that such a unique
vocal talent has been teamed with meandering and annoying musical
compositions.
It is more than frustrating
when a band appears to go out of its way to collectively destroy
the musicality of a song. You get the feeling that The Young People
are forcing themselves to take their songs on an abstract and disjointing
musical journey. Someone should inform them that there is nothing
wrong with performing a song in a proper musical form. If The Young
People ever lay back and let Eastburn's vocals take the reins, than
this will be a band worth listening to.
back
to
Posted Nov. 21,
2003. Copyright © 2003 Tim McMahan. All rights reserved.
|
|
Rating: No
|
|
Obligatory pull-quote:
"Some
may call them a challenging band; a terribly mediocre and tuneless
group is more appropriate." |
|
Tim Sez:
It
has the same resonance as P.J. Harvey's 4-track stuff, Scout
Niblett and Cat Power,but it's jumpier and more playful than
all of them. I don't find them particularly experimental as
much as jarring and dissonant, thanks to Eastburn's insistence
on singing off-key during some of the loud parts. There are
times, like on "Rhumba" and "Ask About the
Dust" where Eastburn's enthusiasm channels Nancy Sinatra,
ironically at least. Most of these simple tunes are only a
couple minutes long. All are propelled by Joe Plummer's booming,
big-band-style drums. Sure, it's arty and thumbs its nose
at the traditionalist who insist on a clean, easy melody with
smooth, curved edges. The Young People don't care if you cut
your finger on a misplaced shard of broken glass. If you were
looking for a safe, quiet place to lay your head, you should
have bought a Nora Jones album.
Tim's rating:
Yes
|
|